A slice of pecan pie next to a scoop of ice cream, a sprig of mint, a few loose pecans on a blue plate

How To Texas is a recurring column offering step-by-step instructions on how to be Texan. We’ll guide you through the cultural traditions, customs, eccentricities, lifestyles, and activities you’ll find on your travels that make the state uniquely Texan.

How to Make Pecan Pie

Nobody really knows why, but the pecan pie is the champion of Turkey Day in Texas. Every Thanksgiving, the eminently popular sweets slingers at Royers Pie Haven in Round Top see a major uptick in pecan pie orders. 

“For Christmas, not so much,” owner Tara Royer Steele says. “Everyone has chocolate for Christmas.”

But for the month of November, particularly when Texans are parked on their couches, bellies full and screaming at the Dallas Cowboys on TV, the humble pecan pie reigns supreme. It has been that way for a long time; the earliest pecan pie recipes were printed in Texas cookbooks as far back as the 1870s. 

Royer Steele doesn’t have a concrete answer for why Texans love the nutty, syrupy confection so much. She chalks it up to availability and nostalgia: picking pecans from the ground as a child and bringing them to grandma to use in a pie. People still bring Royers Pie Haven bags of pecans they’ve collected from their yards.

The pecan tree is also the Texas state tree (and, as of 2013, the pecan pie the official state pie). With the exception of the state bird (sorry, dear mockingbird), we celebrate our symbols.

“When we do things in Texas, we love them,” Royer Steele says, “and we let everybody know how awesome they are.”

Texas Highways logo Subscribe

How to make PECAN PIE

tip no. 1: Keep It Simple

You probably have most of the ingredients for a pecan pie in your cupboard. 

“You just need a pie shell, some pecans, and four or five ingredients: eggs, sugar, Karo syrup, vanilla, and salt,” Royer Steele says. “In an hour, you can have a pie.”

Royer Steele says that her pecan pies use the milder light Karo syrup instead of the dark version, for a simple reason: the pies don’t need any extra sweetness, not with the added sugar and (spoiler alert) ice cream atop.

tip No. 2: Play the Shell Game

Royer does not freeze pie shells because doing so could introduce cracks, which would lead to leaky pies. They pour the filling into room temperature shells and within seconds, they are ready to eat.

“Some pies you need to let sit and set a bit, but this one, straight out of the oven … that caramel smell,” she says, “It’s so good.”

tip No. 3: Start From the Bottom

Royer’s uses junior mammoth pecan pieces in their sugar-free pecan pies so that they can tell them apart from the traditional ones, which use whole pecans. And while the process is pretty simple, they do have one particular way in which they layer the filling.

“We put the pecans on the bottom first,” Royer Steele says, “and then pour the filling and the pecans will rise to the top.”

tip no. 4: give yourself grace

Sometimes one does not have the energy, patience, or literal ingredients required to make the Platonic ideal of a pecan pie, complete with a homemade crust. Still, granny is not rolling in her grave as you pull the premade crust from the fridge.

“Make your crust … or, don’t even make your crust. It’s OK,” Royer Steele says. “You can use Pillsbury. That’s what I use if I don’t have a crust around or I don’t have the time to make one.”

The goal here is pecan pie, any way you can get it. Don’t let the pursuit of perfection get in the way.

tip no. 5: Stay Cool

“We think all pie needs ice cream,” Royer Steele says. “Blue Bell vanilla is just the best.” 

If you’re reheating a single slice in the microwave, don’t nuke the thing into oblivion. Otherwise, you’ll have sizzling filling that can burn the roof of your mouth.

“Just from experience, take it from me,” Royer Steele says. Also, she continues, if it’s too hot when you go a la mode mode, “you’ll get soupy ice cream.”

tip no. 6: Shake it up

Royer’s makes pie shakes, which are exactly what they sound like. Blend a slice of pecan pie, two scoops of vanilla ice cream, and a splash of milk, and top with whipped cream.

“I will drink a pecan pie shake any day, every day,” Royers says. “Eat your slice of pie or drink your slice of pie this Thanksgiving.”

tip no. 7: get experimental

The traditional pecan pie is always a crowd pleaser at a Texan Thanksgiving. Why not stand out with a showstopper?

“If you want to add a little twist to your pecan pie,” Royer Steele says, “throw in a cup of chocolate chips or sweetened coconut flakes.”

She says that experimenting in the kitchen is how new classics are born.

“That’s how we make some of our best pies,” she says. “We screwed up and were like, ‘Oh my God, this is the best thing ever.’”

Speaking of …

Get more Texas in your inbox

Sign up for our newsletters and never miss a moment of what's happening around the state.